Mirels’ Criteria for Prophylactic Fixation

Fracture risk at 6 months post-irradiation

Mirels’ Criteria: Scores lesion site, pain, radiographic appearance, and size to estimate pathologic fracture risk and guide prophylactic fixation.

Site of lesion
Upper limb+1Lower limb+2Trochanteric region+3
Size of lesion
Less than 1/3 of bone diameter+11/3 to 2/3 of bone diameter+2More than 2/3 of bone diameter+3
Nature of lesion
Blastic+1Mixed+2Lytic+3
Pain
Mild+1Moderate+2Functional+3

使用適応

Prophylactic fixation is indicated when fracture risk is high: Mirels ≥9 for lower limb or ≥7–8 for upper limb, especially with lytic lesions, >50% cortical destruction, or persistent pain with weight‑bearing 1 [Level II evidence]; humeral data support ≥8 cutoff 2 [Level III evidence]. Clinically useful for rapid, sensitive screening to prevent pathologic fractures and guide referral for stabilization 3 [Level III evidence].

洞察と注意事項

Prophylactic fixation is generally considered when scores are high but must be tempered by tool imprecision. Scores ≥9 risk overestimating fractures (specificity ~50%) based on prospective data 1 [Level II evidence]. Upper‑limb lesions may fracture at lower thresholds (≥7–8) 2 [Level III evidence]. Interobserver reliability is only fair–moderate, limiting reproducibility 3 [Level III evidence]. Consider cortical breach and CT‑based biomechanical tools for higher specificity.